Who would have known that American Idol would have ever afforded me the opportunity to teach a life lesson to my boys.
I must start by admitting that I was never a Megan Joy fan – there, its out there. BUT, even though I wasn’t a fan of her singing style, my problem with her tonight had nothing to do with her vocals.
I noticed over the last several weeks that when an Idol judge would offer criticism she would say she didn’t agree. Most of the other contestants would usually say that they would consider the judges remarks, but not Megan. There was an obvious disinterest in hearing anything but positive commentary. Tonight, she even went so far as to say that she didn’t care what Simon had told her the night before. Really? You’re trying to win a singing competition and you can’t bring yourself to accept constructive criticism? You want to have a successful music career but you aren’t going to listen to those who don’t have the same opinion you do – even if they are looking out for your best interest?
Just imagine what most record producers were thinking . . . “I don’t want to work with her.” Have you ever tried to work with/for someone who wouldn’t take input? Did you enjoy it? Have you ever tried to help someone who refused to listen to any point of view other than their own? Have you ever known someone who believed that if you had any disagreement with the way they did something than it must mean you didn’t like them as a person or better yet, that something was wrong with you? It’s like beating you head against a wall! The “its my way or the high way” belief – astounding.
How can anyone expect to grow if they aren’t willing to accept honest, caring feedback about their actions, behaviors and choices?
So here were my questions:
How could she have handled the situation differently? Does it make you weaker or less of a person if someone else doesn’t agree with you or the way you choose to do something? What does it say about you if you are only willing to listen to people’s positive comments? If someone (a relative, close friend, superior, etc) comes to you and tells you they disagree with you or see an area of concern and your first response is to become angry, what is that telling you? If you hear the same feedback on numerous occassions and still refuse to hear – well you get the point. Something is out of balance.
My problem with Megan isn’t that she disagreed with the judges. My problem with Megan was the disrespectful way in which she told them she didn’t agree and the obvious lack of interest in what they had to say. It was the attitude of: If you don’t agree than I don’t need you. Granted, we can’t listen to and accept every negative thing people say about us. If we did we’d be in a fetal position and never leave our homes. But, we also can’t surround ourselves with people who care about us and allow them to be a part of our lives only if they agree with us 100% of the time. And, if we truly don’t agree with their input but respect them, isn’t there a better, more gracious way to reply?
What was the consequence for Megan’s choice to tell the world that she didn’t care about what Simon had said? I thought Simon (as annoying as he can be) was spot on in returning her disrespectful action by saying – “then we won’t even consider saving you”. In other words, why should we honor you when you acted so disrespectfully towards us? We don’t owe you an audience. If our opinion is of so little value than we shouldn’t have to waste our time in giving you another chance. Why would we put ourselves out there only to have you respond in the same manner? Why should we give you more consideration than you are willing to give us?
Now Megan said she didn’t care – but did you see how upset she was to be going home? The reality is – she did care. But, (in my opinion) maybe she cared in an unhealthy way. Maybe she took the feedback personally. Rather than hearing what was actually being said which was: “Your song choice was wrong. You aren’t being yourself. You are trying to be someone you’re not – you were good just the way you were when we first saw you. Don’t change now in order to please everyone else.” What she heard was: “You’re not good enough. You can’t sing. We don’t like you.” Maybe that’s why she responded the way she did. She couldn’t differentiate between someone saying “I don’t like what you’re doing from I don’t like you.” So, her defenses went up and in order to keep herself from hurting she had to try to convince herself and everyone watching that she just didn’t care. But did anyone actually buy it? We know Simon didn’t. When he heard Ryan proclaim: “She said she didn’t care what you had to say.” Simon’s response was: “Oh yes she did.”
So, the lesson for my children: You should not be open up to everyone’s critique and not everyone has the right to speak into your life. However, when it comes to people who love you and care for you (a teacher, coach, future boss, spouse or close friend) whom you know have your best interest in mind, graciously accept advice and if you don’t agree, than respectfully agree to disagree. Everyone needs correction. Everyone needs advice. Everyone needs another opinion about important issues. It doesn’t make you less of a person to graciously listen and consider their words – whether you choose to apply them or not is another story – but give people the respect they deserve and perhaps have earned and listen. Maybe they’re actually right.
In this particular case with Megan, Simon was right and Megan went home. Maybe she should have been more open to the warnings in the two previous weeks. Maybe she should have graciously taken a little advice.